CMR vs SMR: Which Hard Drive Technology Is The Best For You

CMR and SMR are methods to store data on hard drives. Each one has a significant part in the storage device performance. SMR stands for Shingled Magnetic Recording, while CMR stands for Conventional Magnetic Recording.

SMR is a relatively new technology that some of the leading manufacturers of hard drives, such as Western Digital and Seagate, have introduced. CMR is an old technology that was first used in the early 90s by many hard drive manufacturers, such as Maxtor and Quantum (now known as Hitachi).

Choosing which technology to use on your HDD is one step that can prevent you from making the wrong investment.

But not always the manufacturer adds this information to the driver’s description. Inquire about this information so you can have the best data storage device for your purpose.

Top Summary: The best way to decide if you should use CMR or SMR is to know their differences and apply them to your needs. No technology is perfect, but there is one most suitable for each user’s needs.

Top differences: SMR vs CMR

Both SMR and CMR technologies have their pros and cons, meaning that to choose between them, you need to have a goal and match the technology that best fulfills it. 

Speed – CMR

For speed, CMR is the clear winner. It stores data in separate tracks on a CMR hard drive, which allows for much higher data densities. This results in faster data transfer rates and shorter access times. In contrast, data on an SMR hard drive is stored in overlapping tracks. This means that it can have more data stored in an area, but it also slows down data transfer rates and increases access times.

Reliability – SMR

SMR drives are more reliable than CMR drives. Since it stores data in overlapping tracks, there is a lower risk of interruption when reading or writing data. 

In comparison, this might be an issue with CMR hard drives where the magnetic head can easily hit the edge of the disk and cause damage to it and interrupt the process. 

This increased reliability is one of the main reasons SMR technology has become popular among enterprise users who require high levels of data integrity and uptime.

Price – CMR

If you have a limited budget and price is a big aspect of your decision, the CMR is at the top of your choice list.

SMRs are more expensive than CMR, since they have different manufacturing costs.

Storage capability – SMR

SMR hard drive stores the data in overlapping tracks. This increases the real density of the disk – the amount of data that can be stored in an area. In contrast, it can easily decrease speed and overflow the cache as you constantly write and rewrite it.

Writing Performance – CMR

With constant writing and rewriting, SMR can have cache overflow. Meanwhile, CMR supports large amounts of data transfer at a high speed. If you have to use constantly your drive or need to change data and access it fast, CMR is then your best choice.

Summary: The type of hard drive you should get – SMR or CMR, depends on your needs and what you’re going to use your drive for. If speed is important to you, then CMR is the better choice. However, if you need a hard drive with higher data capacity, then SMR might be the better option.

Hard Drives brands and models that are CMR or SMR

Which Hard Drives are CMR compatible and which are SMR compatible? Seagate, Toshiba, and WD hard drives have models for each technology. 

Here’s a complete list that compiles the manufacturers, the HDD’s models, and capacities in one place.